Consign Your Gear

Turn your quality used items into cash when you consign with Carlisle Athletic Company

Click here to see how it works

*If you are bringing more than 10 items please call to make an appointment with us (717)-254-6799*

Disc Golf

Carlisle Athletic Company carries new/used discs, disc golf accessories, factory second discs, and quality used discs. Brands we carry:


-Dynamic Discs



-Latitude 64



About US

Kristina Witman: Owner

Kristina Witman, started the Carlisle Athletic Company as a business student at HACC in 2019. Then, a single parent to 4 and full-time student she felt the financial strain of having to purchase new sports equipment every season for her oldest son who was involved in multiple sports. Realizing the outgrown equipment still had a lot of life left to be played... the idea for Carlisle Athletic Company was born.

Misson Statement

To inspire active lifestyles by providing high quality, recycled, sporting goods, and workout apparel to all athletes at an affordable price.

Vision Statement

To lessen the financial burden associated with playing sports. We also strive to reduce our community’s carbon footprint by recycling sporting goods/apparel and eliminating single use plastic bags in our store.

We are a reusable bag store!

Bring Your Own Bag

...or purchase one of our Carlisle Athletic Co Bags!

Our Store

45 Army Heritage Drive Carlisle, PA 17013


Customer Testimonials

"I hate paying full price for anything, and why buy new when you can buy something that looks new for a quarter of the price at Carlisle Athletic Company."

Aaron Barrick

"I love to be able to trade in items and apparel that I no longer use/need at Carlisle Athletic Company AND also find great prices on things I CAN use!"

Penny Parks-Dean

"I definetly like coming back to Carlisle Athletic Company, the store has a great vibe!"

Giovanni Andreoli

"I have had a good experience selling and buying items at Carlisle Athletic Company. Thank you for opening!"

Dru Wagner